Kantonsspital St.Gallen

How many radiographs are needed to detect angular stable head screw cut outs of the proximal humerus - A cadaver study

Christian Spross, Bernhard Jost, Stefan Rahm, Sebastian Winklhofer, Johannes Erhardt & Emanuel Benninger


Cut out of locking head screws is the most common complication of locking plates in fracture fixation of the proximal humerus with potentially disastrous consequences. Aim of the study was to find the single best and combination of radiographic projections to reliably detect screw cut outs.

The locking plate was fixed to six cadaveric proximal humeri. Six different radiographs were performed: anteriorposterior in internal (apIR), in neutral (ap0) and in 30° external rotation (apER); axial in 30° (ax30) and 60° (ax60) abduction and an outlet view. Each head screw (n=9) was sequentially exchanged to perforate the humeral head with the tip and all radiographs were repeated for each cut out. Randomized image reading by two blinded examiners for cut out was done for single projection and combinations.

Interrater agreement was 0.72-0.93. Best single projection was ax30 (sensitivity 76%) and the worst was the outlet view (sens. 17%). Standard combination of apIR/outlet reached a sens. of 54%. The best combination of two was: apER/ax30 (90% sens.), of three: apIR/apER/ax30 (96% sens.) and of four: apIR/ap0/apER/ax30 (100% sens.).

Standard radiographs (ap/outlet), especially in internal rotation, may miss nearly half of screw cut outs. Single best radiographic projection was an axial view with 30° abduction. To account for all cut outs and correct screw position a combination of four projections was needed. These simple and feasible intraoperative and postoperative radiographs help to detect screw perforations of the locking plate reliably.

I (Study of Diagnostic Test).
citation Spross C, Jost B, Rahm S, Winklhofer S, erhardt j, Benninger E. How many radiographs are needed to detect angular stable head screw cut outs of the proximal humerus - A cadaver study. Injury 2014; 45:1557-63.
type journal paper/review (English)
date of publishing 28-05-2014
journal title Injury (45/10)
ISSN electronic 1879-0267
pages 1557-63
PubMed 24934611
DOI 10.1016/j.injury.2014.05.025